Mentionsy Mentionsy
Podcast AV iT
Podcast AV iT

This AV Mistake Will Cost You a Fortune! IPMX & Open Standards Breakdow

02.10.2026 ·23 min 35 s · 8 rozdziałów

What is the difference between an open standard and open source?What is interoperability in the AV world and why is "everything works with everything" a myth?How does IPMX compare to NDI, SDVOE, or Dante?⭐ In this episode of the AV IT Technology Podcast, Rob Moody from Matrox Video.👥 Host - Mariusz OrzechowskiChapters: 00:00 - 00:31 - Introduction00:32 - 02:45 - What are open standards?02:06 - 04:00 - Open standard vs open source - differences04:01 - 06:53 - Interoperability06:54 - 14:16 - IPMX standard14:17 - 17:18 - IPMX - advantages compared to NDI, SDVOE, Dante17:19 - 20:37 - The future of AV over IP20:38 - 23:30 - Advice: how to save money and time on investments We discuss how to effectively mix technologies from different brands and why flexibility is the key to success in the industry. There will be examples of hybrid installations and advice on how to design systems with flexibility and cost savings in mind.Enjoy listening 🎧 📅 Want to see IPMX technology in action and talk to the expert live? Meet Rob Moody on October 7-8 at the Matrox Video booth during ProAV IT Competence Days in Kraków!

0:00 · Introdukcja i pytania 4

Podcast Technologia AV iT. Rozmawiamy o profesjonalnych rozwiązaniach i najnowszych trendach audio-video. Porozmawiajmy o audio, porozmawiajmy o wideo. One wrong choice at the start can double your cost. Technology is changing fast, so very important question is what should you use right now and what you should avoid. Today we break down AV over IP, open standards, IPMX and how cross-technology let you mix different brands. Let's talk with expert about it. To get proper answers I ask Rob Moody from Matrox Video to help me explain all details. Rob, witaj na kanale AV iT. Jestem bardzo zadowolony, że tu jestem.

Dziękuję za zaproszenie. It is our pleasure. Rob, you are a well-known specialist from the open standards on the market. That's why I would like to use this opportunity and ask you about that. And first question to you. We hear a lot about these open standards in AV over IP industry. If we are discussing with the person who is new on this market and he or she don't know anything about this, how you can explain what does it mean, open standards here? I think the first thing to say about being an open standard is it belongs to everyone rather than a small group of people. It's not owned by a manufacturer. It's not steered by a group of manufacturers who are self-defined.

It's put together by a group of experts from the industry who can bring together all of their various expertises over their careers and from within their companies to make something that's better for everyone. I jest bardzo dobry powód, dlaczego chciałbyś taki standard. To sprawia, że jest niezależny od producentów. Producent może przeszkodzić komercyjnie, może zmienić kierunkę i nie ma efektu na open standard. I to jest bardzo inny od tego typu standardów, które są naprawdę standardami producentów. Powiedzą, że jest wolno używać mojego API, więc jest otwarte. Ale to nie jest tak. Gdy wychodzą, to już nie są tam.

Gdy zaczną się rozwijać, to zaczną się rozwijać. Przedstawia się, oczywiście, Open Standard. I to jest naprawdę ważne dla firm AV, które planują na przyszłość. Nie wiedzą, co będzie w przyszłości. Nie wiem, co będzie w przyszłości. Ale chcielibyśmy jak najmniej zrozumieć, że ten standard wciąż będzie tam. To naprawdę warto. Ok, myślę, że to jest wystarczająco jasne. Myślę, że wielu ludzi zna open source jako terminologię itp. Więc jaka jest różnica pomiędzy open standardem a open sourcem? Ponieważ open sourcem wiemy od strony software'a itp. Więc myślę, że to jest bardziej zwykła wiedza o tym. Jeśli możesz wyjaśnić różnicę.

3:08 · Interoperability w AV 2

That's a very good question and I hear a lot of people who somehow manage to confuse the two or think they mean the same thing. So we know what an open standard is. Open source is about the code. With open source code you can see what the coder wrote. It's not being compiled. You've got more than run rights. You can see the code. Open standards of course, they're documents, there isn't code. So it's not a case of making the code available to somebody, because that's telling you how I did it, whereas the open standard is defining what you need to do. Ja, clear. I think this is also very important to understand this difference, because for many people maybe open source is the same like open standards.

So such explanation I think is here very, very important. Powiedziałeś, że Open Standards oznacza, że jesteśmy niezależni od producenta, niezależni od tego, jakie produkty używamy. To jest dla mnie bardzo magiczne słowo. Interoperability for me is a little bit difficult to say. A very long word. And what does it mean really in the AV market? I think this is connected with this universal standards that you can work with every unit, correct? Or can you explain more? Oczywiście, to oznacza współpracę, ale to nie jest tak proste jak to.

4:41 · IPMX - opis i znaczenie 1

And then there became a little obstacle, a hill that we had to get over. Can we make the HDCP work? That got even more difficult when it was over the network. Więc potrzebujemy trochę puzzle'ów. Każda kawałka powinna pracować razem. Ok, rozmawialiśmy o sygnalach, kodowaniu, decodowaniu, więc zacznijmy od decodowania IPMX. Mamy standardowy IPMX. Jeśli możesz wyjaśnić, co to jest? Jaki jest jego background i dlaczego jest ważny dzisiaj?

7:10 · Historia i rozwój IPMX 5

IPMX to jest rachunka opublikowanych standardów i wyznaczonych specyfikacji. Wszystkie te specyfikacje są złożone w celu tego, żeby zrobić trzy rzeczy. Pierwsza rzecz to przerabianie real-time media na rynku. Real-time, bez względu na to, czy jest to gracz, czy jest to live, to się dzieje w real-time. Nie przerabia się dźwięk. The second is interoperability, that it should work in that way and it should be secure and available to everybody as well. And it's based on one of those published standards, the SMPTE ST2110. SMPTE is the Society of Motion Picture and Television Engineers. They standardize many things, including ST2110, which is what the broadcast industry use for moving their audio and video at the highest level in their studios and their facilities houses.

It was designed for that purpose. And in the AV world, yes, we have audio and video in common with them, but we have a lot of different things. I mentioned HDCP. EDID is another one. When we connect to a monitor, there's an exchange that tells us what that monitor, that projector can do. W naszym świecie zazwyczaj używamy RGB, a studia obecnie używają YUV, więc jest wiele różnic. IPMX wstrzymał ST2110, aby wprowadzić wszystkie te różnice. I jeśli popatrzymy na to z innej strony, to wstrzymał ST2110 na live eventy, a także na high-end AV, pro-AV, gdzie nie było bardzo dobrze łączone.

That's a very good thing for IPMX. It opens a much larger market. Larger markets are good for everybody because there's more competition and there's more opportunity for growth. IPMX is pretty new, but this is not fresh. I think this is existing on the market a couple of years already. Very much so, yes. As a company, Matrox, we've been shipping products for ...four years, I think, that have been designed with this product, this standard in mind. And we are one of the companies who've contributed our engineers to the efforts to create it, so we had a very good idea what was happening.

But because it's an open standard, all of the drafts have been online. Everybody, every manufacturer could see this coming. And as the drafts started to converge, there were fewer and fewer changes with every review, then the manufacturers started to be confident that they could design and build products that were ready. For years there have been IPMX ready things. And once the standards body started publishing the final version of the standards, and this was the Video Services Forum . Once they started publishing TR10, that's their standard technical recommendation 10, it became very obvious to everybody what was needed and you could now produce the products against that.

Those IPMX products have been around depending on which manufacturer for two, three, four years, some new ones of course, but because they're based on ST2110, Correct. I will maybe add one point here to our viewers to understand what IPMX really means in the wording. I will read it. Internet Protocol Media Experience. This is the full name of this protocol. Proper meaning and understanding what the name means. Rob, let's talk also about the different standards, because IPMX is an open standard that we have, but people also know from the market, you mentioned already some of them, NDI, SDVoE, Dante and so on and so on.

10:53 · Inne standardy w branży AV 3

Could you say something more about the other standards and how it is corresponding to the open world of standards? Oczywiście. Wiele standardów, które się rozwijały w ostatnich kilku latach, nie są otwarte. Są skierowane do technologii producenta. Może jest to pewien intergralny cyrkut, czop w środku, a wszystkie produkty, które podążają za tym standardem, mają ten czop. Widzimy tu bardzo ostrożną relację producenta. Or maybe it's based on, that would, for example, be SDV over E. All SDV over E products have a chip from Semtech in the middle of them. That particular standard happens to work at 10 gigabit per second.

It needs that sort of network. And it's focused at a particular group of users who need the bandwidth and the very low latency that is delivered with those 10 gig networks. NDI is very popular in the video industry. Again, that's based around some code that used to be NewTek, now it's PISRT. And that's a one gig technology. So if you're dealing with high quality imagery, an uncompressed UHD 60, that takes IPMX Open Standards Breakdow.

Obviously it's not based on any of that manufacturer technology, but it's got the widest footprint. It can do uncompressed UHD 60, it can do lightly compressed, Which would take you into the one gigabit per second top end. And it's moving very rapidly towards the highly compressed H264, H265 end of the user needs. And there's no other approach that has got all of those things covered. So each of those standards brings something to the party. They've been designed to bring that something. And whether it's right for a particular group of users depends on how well they did it. But if it's been right for group A, it's probably not right for group B. So if it's narrow and purposeful, that means it will have limitations.

14:19 · Hybrydowe rozwiązania w AV 4

Rob, jeśli rozmawiamy o tej technologii zrównoważonej, to teraz pozwólmy na przykład do naszych widzów. Jak wspomniałeś, NDI to są głównie kamery, które mają te standardy. Czy są jakieś inne sprzęty? IPMX Open Standards Breakdow.

I think the reality of almost everybody in AV is that most projects are hybrid. They've got some legacy equipment, some legacy assets that are not going to change. They're making a small investment now that will help them to move towards their strategic objective. And that's the reality that standards like IPMX exist in. It's a very good idea, people can see it as a wonderful environment to have, but they can't get there in one step. To oznacza, że potrzebna jest strzałka, droga do dojścia do tego, a to oznacza klasę produktów, których możemy nazwać konwerterami lub adaptatorami, które mogą zmienić te standardy.

To zawsze było możliwe. Tradycyjnie, jeśli byłbyś w standardzie A, wchodzisz w wideo, wchodzisz do tego standardu, You'd make the move and you'd decode out of that standard back to SDI or HDMI again. That's a conversion stage. Then you could go into some other standard. When you come out as HDMI or SDI, you've lost a number of things. You're no longer trackable within the network by the network tools. You've lost the routing capability that's in the network and you've lost the security that's in the network. It's much better to have those conversions done in a network device on the network.

So network in, network out. I ta klasa konwerterów to to, co pozwala na połączenie NDI, SRT, RTSP, H.264, H.265. Wszystkie te rzeczy, których każdy ma dużo, mogą być konwertywowane, wewnątrz ruchu, do jakiegoś wspólnego pomysłu, The way IPMX works is it carries the audio and the video and the metadata as three separate streams. So, it looks like this is the future for these open standards. Rob, you are very long in this industry, also as me, and you remember many, many other things in the past, analog, today we have digital, we have over IP.

17:22 · Perspektywy przyszłości 2

If you can compare all these things and what do you think, what is the future of this industry with over IP standards? That's a really important question. I I think one of the things that characterizes all of our careers, whether we look at our whole career or small parts of it, is change. There is always change. We like to have some things the same as we did last time, but we can't always do that. When I started out in this industry, everything was analogue and I lived through the change from analogue to firstly SDI and then the introduction of MPEG and transmission of digital into the televisions in our own homes.

And at each stage the engineers have said, do we need to do this? Surely it's good enough already? And I hear that today from AV engineers, do we need over IP? Aren't we good enough already? And it's very good, but the future is IP. Everything is going to IP. So we as AV engineers really need to bring that skill into our own personal toolbox. Myślę, że ludzie czasami są ostrożni od zmiany, ponieważ czasami pracujecie w komfortowej zonie i jeśli potrzebujecie jakichś zmian, to jesteście trochę straszni, czy powinienem to zrobić, czy nie. To jest również w naszej normalnej życiu, nie tylko w IPMX. Może też czasami to jest powód, ale myślę, że nie ma wyboru.

Pokazano wszystkie 21 dopasowań. Transkrypcja generowana automatycznie i niesprawdzana ręcznie — może zawierać błędy.